Suspended ban for Brookes
Recommended Comment

RECOMMENDED COMMENT

44 agree. 7 disagree.
Report Abuse
Idiot got off with a light sentence! :rolleyes:
Posted by R6ex - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Recommended Comment
Sort Comments: Oldest   |   Newest

BSB » Suspended ban for Brookes

Josh Brookes receives a one race ban, suspended for three meetings, following further investigations owing to his collision with Sylvain Guintoli.

Add Comment

Have Your Say Comments
1 agrees.
Report Abuse
Not the best of weeks for French Superbike riders really. Nor for anyone in the MCN Fantasy Road Race competition with Laconi or Guintoli either :?.
Thankfully not me... I had Ellison from day 1 :p
Posted by Nitro Nori (185 days ago)
Last Edited 185 days ago
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
15 agree. 7 disagree.
Report Abuse
Big Tip for LittleG..... It takes 2 to tango. Josh should have shown much, much more care.... Sylvain should perhaps have been off the racing line.... But to go Aussie bashing is pathetic and juvenile. Both riders are class acts and will remain so. Josh has won 2 rounds in WSS (one as a wild card !) and did win the SS / SBK double in Aussie. So pull ya head in mate...
Posted by Jack - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
3 agree. 3 disagree.
Report Abuse
It's a bit ironic how this happened to Sylvain. Anyone remember the Sylvain and Hoffman incident at the top of the corkscrew last year?
Posted by Bigwl3 . (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
2 disagree.
Report Abuse
I'm sure that Brookes did not mean it - a racing incident pure and simple :blush:. The only real loser is BSB. With so few top riders and so many visits to r****-dink circuits in the middle of nowhere we need all the quality people at big circuits that we can get to prevent it becoming an Airwaves benefit show (no insult intended Colin W)
Posted by nacnud - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
2 agree. 14 disagree.
Report Abuse
Not meaning is no excuse. Seems he messed up and lied about it, so one race is a very light senntence.
Anyway , wish SG a quick recovery, but can't avoid thinking of kharma ... laguna seca, alex hoffmann
Posted by Brown GP - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
1 agrees.
Report Abuse
Nacnud! How could it be a racing incident when you are not racing until the end of the sighting lap. It was a silly mistake and racing speeds are not expected by anyone on this lap as it is designed to check out the circuit, bikes and tyres before racing begins.
Posted by Unfazed - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
1 agrees.
Report Abuse
Its a bloody shame, it was a good couple of races but not at all what it should have been like, i was expecting an epic with SG knowing the circuit & also brooks having riden here leon was quick it should have been a nail biter, but well done CW for putting up a spirited race lets see more of that from Chris & also Andrews n Da costa good to see the grteen machines back n working well, the ban is more of a formality maybe? organisers are dambed both ways? yes he deserves a punishment but we loose in the end with less riders to race & brooks can do that well. lets hope that Sylvan gets well soon & is back racing, i wish him a speedy recovery, as for Rutter riding the Suzuki? im not sure, GL
Posted by Steve Scragg (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
4 agree. 2 disagree.
Report Abuse
I think the bigger issue here is why it was claimed by Brookes that the brakes failed (when it later showed he was approaching racing speeds just before the incident) and how the bike apparently had brakes both before and after the crash? Seems to me like he was trying to duck from blame and has been found out. (Something McLaren in F1 were accused of only recently) I would have thought better of him if he had just held his hand up and admitted it was an unfortunate mistake from the start.
Posted by Buelliful . (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
16 agree.
Report Abuse
Agreed that the lie was probably worse than the mistake. HM Plant should probably issue their own punishment, as a statement that such behaviour is not acceptable. Motorcycle racing is a dangerous sport and it requires people to ride sensibly and with total concentration, and crucially with respect for your fellow competitors - something Brookes has completely breached here.
Posted by Martin - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments
Have Your Say Comments
5 disagree.
Report Abuse
sack him he has clearly not commited
Posted by on the goon - Unregistered (185 days ago)
Have Your Say Comments

Have Your Say Comments
Page 2 of 6
« 1 2 3 4 5 6  »
Have Your Say Comments


Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us using the [Report Abuse] function next to the offending comment post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service will be edited or removed with immediate effect. Crash Media Group prohibits defamatory posts.
 
Site Map
© 1999 - 2009 Crash Media Group
The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.

Contact Crash.Net  |  Advertise on Crash.Net  |  Our Privacy Policy  |  About Crash.Net  |  Get News Feeds  |  Need a Website?

Find car reviews on sports cars such as Ferrari, BMW, Porsche and many more.