F1 » Mosley unconvinced by McLaren appeal

Should Max be weighing on this? He didn't when Stepneygate and other controversial issues came up this year. Someone in his position should at least try to maintain an air of neutrality. Why now if there is no alterior motive.

Had the appeal been filled by Ferrari, perhaps it would not have been questioned by Mr. Mosley.
After his silly statments, it is officially certified, the only halfwit in motor racing is no other than Max Mosley himself.

Your'e all a bunch of sore losers, and as for the grumpy doctor, well you need to take some differn't pills mate.

The best man won and now the cheating losers smack of sour grapes.

What a bunch of *******

max, max, max, do the honest thing and step down for gods sake you are making the world of motorsport look stupid!

soamer

It is entertaining to see hypocritical sore looser commentary...

KIMI is the champ, get over it.

FYI ... I am not from Italy, and in fact I supported McLaren until this years crap...

What a bunch of biased souls who refuse to see things straight no matter what...

don't fall out over F1, its not worth it, the open minded views of a president who should uphold a point of neutrality in all issues is obviously flawed with Max, his judgement is clouded before the appeal starts and a fair hearing is certainly not what McLaren will get. If he takes it in his mind to rule Mclaren's appeal frivolous then what else can McLaren do. McLaren should have asked Red Bull to take up the appeal as they would have benefitted with Coulthard geting more points. But no. Then we look back on the season with claims of mclaren using ferrari technical info and yet the Mclaren was unstoppable. (contd)

Ferrari used an illegal device which Stepney spilled the beans on, what happened to them, they were just told to get it off and they kept their points, Alonso should have been promoted and Hamilton second. remember what happened to renualt when their revolutionary mass damper device was discovered it was taken off and who instigated it. And then Honda had to sit out two races as punishment for the fuel tank. Precidents are set and they have to be maintained and seen to be upheld, rules and made and they also have to upheld. but the hypocracy that goes on in Formula One is incredible. Look forward to Valencia for some real motor sport

The Ferrari device was legal when it ran in Australia. It was designed to pass the Tech Regs test and it did. The test was changed after Australia because the FIA felt the Ferrari device was outside the spirit of the Regs even though it complied with the letter. The Renault mass damper was ruled illegal when the FIA discovered it had a significant effect on the aerodynamics of the car and was thus a prohibited aerodynamic device. Clearly it was illegal from day one, unlike the Ferrari floor. derek0113 does not suggest Renault should be penalised. This shows that people like him simply cannot think these things through properly. F1 is a bit too difficult for them.

I don't really want to wade into this as F1 is now so far removed for anything realistic that it defies logic.

The only thing I wanted to clear up is someone saying that Renault had a "revolutionary mass damper device"... these, and devices that perform a similar function, have been used in sports car racing since the 90's

F1 is now so far removed for anything realistic that it defies logic.

Musicracerau I totally agree with your above statement......
I was about to add is it me or has F1 turned to CRAP you summed it up beautifully