F1 »

POLL: Did Renault get the right penalty?

FIA President Max Mosley is adamant that the two-year suspended ban meted out by the World Motor Sport Council to Renault over the 'Singapore-gate' scandal was 'the harshest [penalty] we can impose' – but others are not convinced.

A common school of thought in the Formula 1 paddock is that Renault escaped a hefty fine or, even worse, expulsion from the championship outright purely because the governing body knows it can ill-afford to scare off another manufacturer following the departure of Honda and BMW in the last ten months – and, by all accounts and given the loss of its title sponsor ING and likely loss of its lead driver Fernando Alonso too, the French car maker barely needs any excuse at all to get out.

Based upon the fact that Mosley had described Renault's transgression – in which the Enstone-based outfit's former managing director Flavio Briatore and executive director of engineering Pat Symonds instructed Nelsinho Piquet to deliberately crash out of the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix, in so doing prompting a safety car period that enabled team-mate Fernando Alonso to triumph in the top flight's inaugural night race from a distinctly disadvantaged grid position – as the most serious in F1 history, that the punishment was so comparatively mild has struck some observers as more than a touch disingenuous.

Moreover, the penalty comes less than two years after McLaren-Mercedes was fined a sporting record $100 million for having been found in possession of confidential Ferrari data in the infamous 2007 espionage controversy – a draconian ruling that many felt was more the result of a long-standing personal antipathy between Mosley and former McLaren team principal Ron Dennis than anything else. In the current case, Renault received no fine at all.

So here's your chance to have your say – did the punishment for the crime?

To vote, click here

Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
FIA flag. British Formula One Grand Prix.Silverstone, UK.July 8th 2007.
George Russell, Mercedes junior programme, [Credit: Mercedes]
Valtteri Bottas - Mercedes AMG Petronas
Valtteri Bottas - Mercedes AMG Petronas
Valtteri Bottas - Mercedes AMG Petronas
Valtteri Bottas - Mercedes AMG Petronas
Ayrton Senna - McLaren. 1993 Donington Park
Nico Hulkenberg - Renault Sport F1
Renault Formula One Team, launch date, [Credit: Renault F1]
Force India reveals the launch date for its 2017 F1 challenge
Nigel Mansell - McLaren-Mercedes
M-Sport reveals its Ford Fiesta RS WRC challenger
Who will replace Nico Rosberg at Mercedes?
Who will replace Nico Rosberg at Mercedes?
French Grand Prix at Paul Ricard
Lando Norris, McLaren Autosport BRDC Awards [Credit: Martyn Pass PR]
Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes, Pirelli 2017 tyre test [Credit: Pirelli]
27.11.2016 - Race, Celebration, 2nd place Nico Rosberg (GER) Mercedes AMG F1 W07 Hybrid and Champion 2016 and Lewis Hamilton (GBR) Mercedes AMG F1 W07 Hybrid race winner

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.

Trevor - Unregistered

September 22, 2009 5:32 PM

I have always stood up for F1 when people around me rubbished it in the past, but somehow I see myself starting to understand why people do say bad things about it when the FIA deliver such a megre punishment. It is time that every team (inc. Ferrari) are dealt with the same. The fact that Renault wasn't fined is a joke compared to the McLaren penalty in 2007. Glad Max is going, shame it wasn't a year or so ago. But if Todt does come in I am finished with it as I think it will be just the same. As for not wanting Renault to leave F1, if they want out I think they should go, maybe they have already decided to, watch this space !! P.S. still can't believe Alonso didn't know anything about !!

© 1999 - 2017 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.