F1 »

Jordan: Ferrari must pay for treating public like 'muppets'

Whilst BBC pundit Eddie Jordan contends Ferrari 'must pay the penalty' for the 'blatant' lack of respect it showed fans at Hockenheim, former F1 World Champion Damon Hill has urged the FIA not to 'throw the book' at the Scuderia over the team orders controversy
Ahead of today's potentially pivotal FIA World Motor Sport Council (WMSC) hearing into the Ferrari Hockenheim team orders furore, opinion is divided amongst the sport's experts as to what F1's governing body should do – with Eddie Jordan insisting the team 'must pay' for having treated the public 'like muppets', and Damon Hill conversely arguing that a hefty punishment would not 'fit this particular crime'.

Should the FIA come down hard on Ferrari and drivers Fernando Alonso and Felipe Massa – whose orchestrated switch of positions during the closing stages of the 2010 German Grand Prix in July was the catalyst for the whole team orders controversy to rear its ugly head again, following its official ban back in 2002 – it could well spell the end of the former's title challenge this year, particularly if the Spaniard is stripped of the points he gained for his engineered 'victory', which would leave him a full 66 markers adrift of the world championship lead with just six races left to run. Jordan reckons that would be no less than both driver and team deserve.

“It was very blatant,” the former team owner-turned-BBC F1 pundit told BBC Radio Five Live. “I think they should get a bigger penalty. What happens if Alonso gets away scot-free and goes on to win [the title] by two points from whoever? It will always be seen to be a sham, where breaking the rules pays off, and that is something that can never be acceptable.

“What Ferrari did was they showed no respect to the public, they treated us all like muppets, they broke the rules and they have to pay the penalty.”

The Maranello-based outfit was fined $100,000 in the immediate aftermath of the race for the coded message given out by Massa's race engineer Rob Smedley, who twice informed the Brazilian over the pit-to-car radio that the following Alonso was faster than him – the clear inference being that he should move aside and let his team-mate through to take maximum points, in the light of their respective championship chances. Smedley later thanked Massa for having been so 'magnanimous'.

Whilst the Scuderia's defence argument is likely to hinge upon the fact that no explicit order was given to Massa to let Alonso pass him, former FIA President Max Mosley has professed his opinion that the team orders ban he played a key role in imposing eight years ago should remain in-place and that 'both cars and both drivers should lose the points they achieved in the German Grand Prix' [see separate story – click here].

Jordan claims the outcome of the WMSC reunion will reveal much about the Englishman's successor in the role, erstwhile Ferrari team principal Jean Todt. The Frenchman will not be chairing the hearing due to his old ties with the team, handing over the reins instead to his deputy president, London barrister Graham Stoker.

“Max Mosley didn't always attend these meetings, but his thought process was very much in evidence,” the Irishman explained. “[Todt's] decision will be embedded in that body of people.”

Another school of thought, meanwhile, is that the ban – brought in after Rubens Barrichello slowed dramatically just before the finish line to hand Ferrari team-mate Michael Schumacher the win in the 2002 Austrian Grand Prix, thereby making very evident his displeasure with the instruction he had received from his team – is simply unworkable, with the common consensus being that the Prancing Horse now finds itself in the dock not for having transgressed that ban as rival teams have similarly undoubtedly done, but rather for the clumsy manner in which it did so and the persistent denials afterwards that it had done anything of the sort.

Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
Damon Hill at the launch of the new Silverstone Arena circuit [Pic credit; Silverstone]
British Racing Drivers` Club President Damon Hill with the recovered bronze bust of his father Graham in the BRDC Clubhouse at Silverstone
26.05.2006 Monte Carlo, Monaco, . Eddie Jordan in the Formula 1 paddock - Formula 1 World Championship, Rd 7, Monaco Grand Prix, Friday
Eddie Jordan at the 2010 British Grand Prix Ball [pic credit: Zoom Picture Agency]
Eddie Jordan chats to Jean Todt
Race, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 leads Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Esteban Gutierrez joins Ferrari as test and reserve driver
McLaren confirms Fernando Alonso and Jenson Button
Fernando Alonso and Ron Dennis at McLaren
McLaren confirms Fernando Alonso and Jenson Button
McLaren confirms Fernando Alonso and Jenson Button
Fernando Alonso and Jenson Button alongside Kevin Magnussen. Pic credit: McLaren
McLaren confirms Jenson Button and Fernando Alonso
Michael Andretti drives the MP4/8 in the 1993 San Marino Grand Prix
Lewis Hamilton crowned F1 world champion at FIA Prize-Giving Gala in Qatar [Pic credit: FIA / Jean Marie Hervio / DPPI]
Lewis Hamilton crowned F1 world champion at FIA Prize-Giving Gala in Qatar [Pic credit: FIA / Jean Marie Hervio / DPPI]
Sebastian Vettel in the F2012 during a day testing at Fiorano
Raffaele Marciello (ITA) Ferrari F14-T Test Driver.

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.

James Montgomery

September 08, 2010 1:31 PM

For once I agree with EJ, Ferrari did treat us like muppets after the race by insisting it wasn't team orders when it blatently was. I don't mind team orders... as long as they don't do it in such a pathetic manner like Ferrari did.... Half of this would have been avoided if Smeddly didnt make it so obvious... then keep on appologising to Massa at the end of the race.... so why people are praising him for keeping his mouth shut... I don't know why because it was him who more or less started this whole mess! Eitherway Ferrari shouldn't be punished on how its affected the audience... they should be punished on plain and simply, breaking a rule!

© 1999 - 2014 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.