F1 »

COMMENT: FIA presides over another F1 farce

So come on, who was genuinely surprised that Ferrari escaped further punishment at the hands of the FIA World Motor Sport Council over the Hockenheim team orders controversy? Not this writer, for one...
It would have been nice to have been surprised, in truth. Okay, so maybe nobody really expected the FIA to come down on Ferrari like the proverbial ton of bricks over the Hockenheim team orders furore, but this observer like doubtless many others still secretly had a small ray of hope inside that justice would be served in front of the World Motor Sport Council in Paris on Wednesday. Sadly – and mirroring so many other of the governing body's decisions in recent years – it wasn't.

It was not so much, even, the fact that the Scuderia broke the rules in the German Grand Prix a month-and-a-half ago that caused people's blood to boil – McLaren-Mercedes arguably did the same in the Turkish Grand Prix in Istanbul earlier on in the campaign, albeit with infinitely more subtlety, by instructing Jenson Button to hold station behind team-mate Lewis Hamilton when the defending F1 World Champion palpably wanted to go on the attack – but more the manner in which they did so, betraying a blatant disregard both for fans' intelligence and for the sport's reputation. That was what was so unforgivable.

The ban on team orders was implemented in the first place, lest we forget, due to an incident orchestrated by Ferrari. When Rubens Barrichello was told by his team to move aside to let title-chasing team-mate Michael Schumacher through to artificially 'triumph' in the 2002 Austrian Grand Prix, the Brazilian made evident his distaste for the request by pulling over virtually on the finish line so that all-and-sundry could understand the situation. Clearly embarrassed himself, Schumacher's clumsy attempt to push 'Rubinho' up onto the top step of the podium afterwards was only met with boos and jeers from the crowd. From that moment onwards, team orders in F1 were outlawed.

So the WMSC upheld the initial $100,000 fine the Prancing Horse had been meted out for 'bringing the sport into disrepute'. Whoopie-do. What is $100,000 to a front-running F1 team at the end of the day? Pocket money, small change, a drop in the ocean. Perhaps Messrs. Alonso, Massa and Domenicali will have to do without their morning espresso for the next few grands prix. No great shakes. Just ask McLaren how $100,000 compares to the $100 million they were fined for the 'Spygate' row of 2007.

And that brings us neatly onto another point. Would any other team have had such an easy ride or got away so lightly for such a flagrant transgression of the regulations? Ferrari certainly seems able to stretch the rules further than most without paying the price for it, and whilst Max Mosley may now be gone, paddock whispers that the Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile is actually a cover-up moniker for 'Ferrari International Assistance' remain as strong as ever, and that undoubtedly damages the sport. The fact that Mosley's successor Jean Todt is an ex-team principal at Maranello will only serve to fuel the rumours, regardless of the Frenchman's absence from the WMSC reunion.

Even more laughably, for what had been described as a 'disciplinary' hearing, the only villain in the final reckoning was deemed to be the regulations, which to all intents and purposes means the FIA was less averse to criticising its own creation than it was to condemning Ferrari. Again, the whispers rise up – mustn't blame Ferrari, blame anyone but Ferrari.

Yes, F1 is a team game at the end of the day, and yes, for the big manufacturers and independent outfits that invest millions upon millions of pounds into it every year, it is the constructors' standing that matters the most, but what the billions of fans and TV spectators all around the world want to see is wheel-to-wheel duels between the sport's warriors, and genuine overtaking rather than one driver simply slowing down and waving another one through in a gentlemanly fashion. Besides, if Fernando Alonso is genuinely as good as most people believe him to be, then surely he should have been capable of passing his lesser-rated – and far lesser-paid – team-mate Felipe Massa of his own doing, rather than needing to resort to team tactics. He seemed to have little trouble in muscling his way by on the entry to the pit-lane in Shanghai, remember...

Ultimately, the general consensus inside the F1 paddock is that Ferrari got out-of-jail – again – this week, and that the FIA missed a golden opportunity to clamp down on rule-breakers. What we got on Wednesday was not a judgement, it was a cop-out, and for all that the ruling has kept Alonso's title chances this year just about intact, if the Spaniard does go on to add a third drivers' crown to his impressive career CV come season's end by less than the seven points he unjustly inherited from Massa on that mid-summer's day in Germany, you can't help but feel that his achievement will forever be tarnished.



Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
FIA flag. British Formula One Grand Prix.Silverstone, UK.July 8th 2007.
Race, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 race winner, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 2nd position and Sebastian Vettel (GER), Red Bull Racing, RB6 3rd position
Race, Press conference,  Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 and Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Press conference,  Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 leads Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 leads Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Qualifying, Press conference, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 3rd position
Qualifying, Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 leads Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Felipe Massa (BRA), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 leads Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
18.09.2014 - Scuderia Ferrari F14-T
18.09.2014 - Pastor Maldonado (VEN) Lotus F1 Team E22
18.09.2014 - Felipe Massa (BRA) Williams F1 Team FW36
18.09.2014 - Felipe Massa (BRA) Williams F1 Team FW36
18.09.2014 - Valtteri Bottas (FIN) Williams F1 Team FW36
18.09.2014 - Valtteri Bottas (FIN) Williams F1 Team FW36
18.09.2014 - Bernie Ecclestone (GBR), President and CEO of FOM and Christian Horner (GBR), Red Bull Racing, Sporting Director

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.


ed - Unregistered

September 09, 2010 11:44 AM

Ferrari to FIA radio message: So Jean, Luca is more powerful than you? Can you confirm you understood that message? ... good lad. sorry.



© 1999 - 2014 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.