F1 »

Stewart: calls on Tilke to improve overtaking

Sir Jackie Stewart has called for a change in design theory to improve the F1 show for fans and drivers alike.
Sir Jackie Stewart has called for more individuality among grand prix circuits in a bid to spice up the show, after several seasons where overtaking has been at a premium.

Still frustrated by Fernando Alonso's fruitless attempts to pass Vitaly Petrov and, potentially, go on to claim a third world title in Abu Dhabi late last season, Stewart has claimed that alterations to the most modern of circuits could help improve overtaking more simply than all the technological innovations - such as KERS and adjustable rear wings - being dreamed up and added to the current breed of F1 car.

"In my time, I have been a very keen golfer and, when I think of the great golf courses of the world – from St. Andrews to Pebble Beach to Augusta – they all have green fairways and they all have sandy bunkers," the Scot told Britain's Daily Telegraph newspaper. "Some suit the longer hitters; others place a premium on accuracy, but they each have their own unique characteristics. Crucially, no two of the ones I mentioned were designed by the same person.

"My belief is that the major reason for the lack of overtaking in modern grand prix racing is down to the modern tracks, nearly all of which have been designed by the same man, the German architect Hermann Tilke. I fear he has not done much for the spectators..."

While he praised Tilke for the general improvement in facilities at new venues, he called on the German - who was behind such tracks as Shanghai, Bahrain and Abu Dhabi - to consider making alterations to sections of his designs in order to facilitate overtaking at otherwise sanitised circuits.

"Racetracks have changed since my day - and thank God for that," noted the 71-year-old, a vociferous and highly pro-active advocate for better safety standards in F1 after seeing many of his friends and rivals killed in the 1960s and '70s. "Back then, a driver who raced for five years had a two in three chance of being killed, [and] four to six drivers a year lost their lives. It was totally unacceptable and I campaigned hard for improved safety in the sport, which happily came to pass. It is nearly 17 years since a life was lost in an F1 car, [and] I can't think of an industry, a sport or a business where that standard of risk management has been achieved.

"But we have now gone too far the other way. Circuits should not permit liberties to be abused without a penalty that can be instantly recognised by spectators or TV viewers. Safety is one thing; abuse of privilege is another.

"The new circuits themselves must take their share of the blame. Put simply, they are largely carbon copies of each other and they tend not to penalise mistakes. Take the last race of 2010 for example. There were four drivers who could have clinched the championship in Abu Dhabi, but Ferrari's Fernando Alonso was the overwhelming favourite. He had only to finish fourth to secure his third world crown, [but] it didn't happen because he could not find a way past Vitaly Petrov, a rookie in his first season in F1 and with little or no experience of being under such pressure."

Such was the ability to make a mistake and get away with it in Abu Dhabi, Stewart complains that, as well as finishing higher up the order, Alonso could just as easily have slipped back or gone out of the race altogether.

Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
Thursday, Hermann Tilke (GER), Architect
Race, start
Race, Robert Kubica (POL), Renault F1 Team, R30
Mercedes Benz Safety Car
Race, Vitaly Petrov (RUS), Renault F1 Team, R30 and Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10
Race, Fernando Alonso (ESP), Scuderia Ferrari, F10 and Vitaly Petrov (RUS), Renault F1 Team, R30
Sunday, Sir Jackie Stewart (GBR)
11.06.2017- Race, Sir Patrick Stewart (GBR) Actor
08.06.2017- Romain Grosjean (FRA) Haas F1 Team VF-17 walks the circuit
28.05.2017 - Race, Jacky Ickx (BEL), Stoffel Vandoorne (BEL) McLaren MCL32 and Eddy Merckx
28.05.2017 - Race, , Eddy Merckx (BEL) and Jacky Ickx (BEL)
28.05.2017 - Sir Jackie Stewart (GBR)
28.05.2017 - Sir Jackie Stewart (GBR)
Jackie Stewart (GBR) at the Amber Lounge Fashion Show.
Jackie Stewart (GBR) at the Amber Lounge Fashion Show.
Amber Lounge Fashion Show guests (L to R): Jackie Stewart (GBR); HSH Prince Albert of Monaco (MON); Chase Carey (USA) Formula One Group Chairman; Sean Bratches (USA) Formula 1 Managing Director, Commercial Operations and Ross Brawn (GBR) Managing Director, Motor Sports.
Amber Lounge Fashion Show guests (L to R): Jackie Stewart (GBR); HSH Prince Albert of Monaco (MON); Chase Carey (USA) Formula One Group Chairman.
(L to R): Jackie Stewart (GBR) with HSH Prince Albert of Monaco (MON) and Chase Carey (USA) Formula One Group Chairman, at the Amber Lounge Fashion Show.

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.

© 1999 - 2017 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.