F1 »

Crash.net poll: How should FIA deal with Mercedes test row?

The fall-out from Sunday's news that Mercedes and Pirelli had conducted three days of testing in Barcelona has now come to rest with the FIA, but how should the governing body react?
The revelation, early on raceday morning in Monaco, that Mercedes had conducted a three-day tyre test with Pirelli immediately after the F1 circus had performed in Barcelona cast a shadow over the team's subsequent victory in the Principality, but how seriously should the apparent breach be taken by the FIA?

Both Mercedes and Pirelli insist that the test was above board, with the team suggesting its rivals - who claim they knew nothing of the session - should have twigged something was afoot when the Silver Arrows didn't join the usual rush to pack up and leave the Circuit de Catalunya.

While Red Bull and Ferrari both sought clarity on the situation of being able to test 'for' the tyre supplier, it brought a couple of potentially contentious issues to light - namely that Mercedes provided its 2013 car, already known to be struggling with its tyres, and both race drivers for the 1000km run-out, while apparently contravening a 2012 communication from FOTA clarifying that no such test could be carried out 'in season'....

So, were Mercedes and Pirelli misguided in their actions? Did they believe that the session, which apparently followed a request from the tyre supplier to be able to run with a contemporary car, had been approved by the FIA? Were the necessary invitations offered to the other teams to allow them to witness the test? Was Mercedes being offered a helping hand under the auspices of a Pirelli test? Was there an attempt by the team, despite it denying knowledge of what tyres were fitted when, to claw back the deficit to Red Bull?

These are the sorts of questions that the FIA will no doubt be pondering when it convenes to address the protests lodged by both Mercedes' rivals and the report produced by the stewards after speaking to the various parties in Monaco.

But what do you think? Is there a case to answer and, if so, how should the perpetrators be dealt with? Leaving Pirelli out of the equation for the time being, how should Mercedes' involvement be handled by the powers-that-be?

To have your say, simply see separate story and cast your vote from the options - and don't forget to 'have your say' in the comments section below....



Tagged as: FIA , Mercedes , Barcelona , Pirelli , tyres , test , protest

Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
11.05.2013- Qualifying, Pirelli Tyre
09.05.2013- FIA Hospitality
26.05.2013- Race, Lewis Hamilton (GBR) Mercedes AMG F1 W04
The Lotus F1 E22 running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
The Lotus F1 E22 running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Marussia F1 Team truck in the paddock.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver leaves the pits running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver leaves the pits running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver leaves the pits running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver leaves the pits running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver leaves the pits running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Charles Pic (FRA) Lotus F1 E22 Third Driver leaves the pits running new 18 inch Pirelli tyres and rims.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Kevin Magnussen (DEN) McLaren MP4-29.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Kevin Magnussen (DEN) McLaren MP4-29.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Kevin Magnussen (DEN) McLaren MP4-29.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Daniil Kvyat (RUS) Scuderia Toro Rosso STR9.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.
Daniil Kvyat (RUS) Scuderia Toro Rosso STR9.
09.07.2014. Formula One Testing, Silverstone, England, Wednesday.

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.


Kim - Unregistered

May 28, 2013 11:55 AM

Pirelli & Mercedes hire the Barcelona Circuit for a further three days, invite all the other teams and gives each team 1000km of testing. Same number of tyres for each team as used by Mercedes. All costs incurred by the teams to be covered by Mercedes and Pirelli. Mercedes are of course not allowed to participate in the test.

tim - Unregistered

May 28, 2013 11:30 AM

Perhaps Pirelli should test their tyres on bicycles if they are only allowed to use two year old cars. It's sort of like a software engineer nowadays learning how to program using Windows 3.1



© 1999 - 2014 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.