F1 »

Schumacher crash speed ‘hard to evaluate’

Examination of 'extremely legible' footage provides clues to Michael Schumacher's skiing accident, but prosecutors not focusing on speed.
Police investigations into the skiing accident that has left seven-time F1 world champion Michael Schumacher in a medically-induced coma have yet to determine exactly how fast the German was travelling at the time of his fall, but insist speed is not a key factor in their enquiry.

Schumacher was airlifted to hospital in Grenoble after straying off a marked piste, falling and hitting his head on rocks. He remains in a 'stable but critical' condition according to his manager but, despite showing unexpected signs of improvement following a second operation on New Year's Day, is still 'not out of danger'. Reports claim that the German's helmet, which undoubtedly saved his life, was cracked in the impact, which occurred as he and his party were making their way back to the French resort of Meribel.

Speaking at a specially-convened press conference, designed in part to counter the number of erroneous reports appearing daily, Albertville prosecutor Patrick Quincy confirmed that, while 'extremely legible' footage from Schumacher's helmet-mounted camera showed the accident in 'perfect clarity', it had been hard to determine exactly how fast the German was travelling at the time of the accident. Quincy confirmed that the two-minute film was currently being examined frame by frame in order to establish other factors involved in the incident, but had yet to yield any definite rate of descent, although he insisted that this was not necessarily the cause of the accident.

Quincy revealed that the footage from Schumacher's helmet camera had enable police investigators to exactly determine the path of the German's descent which, having come to an intersection of blue and red runs, opted to follow the slightly more difficult red option, before leaving the piste to its left-hand side.

Although it appears that the German tried to reduce his speed, the nature of the terrain made it difficult to do so, with police commander Stephane Bozon, who formed part of a three-man party on the dais, confirming that Schumacher needed to 'remain in line' in order to negotiate the slope. Both Bozon and Quincy underlined the skill which the German possessed as a skier, but reported that, once his ski had struck a rock, he lost balance and fell, hitting his head on other rocks, some eight metres from the edge of the marked piste. He came to rest a further metre away.

Despite reports to the contrary, the investigators claim that there is no proof that Schumacher had gone to the aid of a fallen skier, and Quincy also cast doubts on the existence of a second film, which German magazine Der Spiegel suggested showed Schumacher's accident happening in the background of family holiday footage.

Quincy subsequently confirmed that piste markers at the scene of the accident were in accordance with French standards, with Bozon emphasising that, even in bad weather, the edge of the run would have been visible. Schumacher's equipment was still being analysed, but there was no immediate concern that it may have played a part in the accident. The skis appeared to be in good working condition, with scratches on the underside consistent with having hit rocks.

Quincy revealed that, far from being a unique occurrence, Schumacher's accident was symptomatic of the 50 or so similar accidents that occur in the region ever season, and was being treated in the same way as any other. He stopped short, however, of absolving anyone of responsibility for the accident.

He had earlier opened the press conference by repeating calls for the media – which had to be accommodated in two rooms such was the interest – to respect the Schumacher family's privacy. There was no comment on the German's condition.



Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
22.11.2012- Michael Schumacher (GER) Mercedes AMG F1 W03
Michael Andretti drives the MP4/8 in the 1993 San Marino Grand Prix
23.11.2014- Sam Michael (AUS) McLaren Sporting Director
22.11.2014 - Michael
21.11.2014 - Free Practice 1, Kevin Magnussen (DEN) McLaren Mercedes MP4-29 and Sam Michael (AUS) McLaren Sporting Director
Michael Schumacher
10.10.2014-   FIA  Press Conference on the accident of Jules Bianchi (FRA) Marussia F1 Team MR03 at the Japanese GP in Suzuka  Charlie Whiting (GBR) FIA Delegate
10.10.2014-   FIA  Press Conference on the accident of Jules Bianchi (FRA) Marussia F1 Team MR03 at the Japanese GP in Suzuka Jean Todt (FRA) FIA President
10.10.2014-   FIA  Press Conference on the accident of Jules Bianchi (FRA) Marussia F1 Team MR03 at the Japanese GP in Suzuka  Charlie Whiting (GBR) FIA Delegate
10.10.2014-   FIA  Press Conference on the accident of Jules Bianchi (FRA) Marussia F1 Team MR03 at the Japanese GP in Suzuka (L to R): Charlie Whiting (GBR) FIA Delegate; Jean Todt (FRA) FIA President; Jean-Charles Piette (FRA) FIA Medical Chief; Dr Ian Roberts (GBR) FIA Doctor
10.10.2014-   FIA  Press Conference on the accident of Jules Bianchi (FRA) Marussia F1 Team MR03 at the Japanese GP in Suzuka (L to R): Charlie Whiting (GBR) FIA Delegate; Jean Todt (FRA) FIA President; Jean-Charles Piette (FRA) FIA Medical Chief; Dr Ian Roberts (GBR) FIA Doctor
10.10.2014-   FIA  Press Conference on the accident of Jules Bianchi (FRA) Marussia F1 Team MR03 at the Japanese GP in Suzuka (L to R): Charlie Whiting (GBR) FIA Delegate; Jean Todt (FRA) FIA President; Jean-Charles Piette (FRA) FIA Medical Chief; Dr Ian Roberts (GBR) FIA Doctor
02.10.2014 - Sam Michael (AUS) McLaren Sporting Director
02.10.2014 - Sam Michael (AUS) McLaren Sporting Director
Mick Junior (Schumacher) secures Karting glory [pic: FIA World Karting]
18.09.2014 - Massimo Rivola (ITA), Scuderia Ferrari Sporting Director and  Michael
27.07.2014- Sam Michael (AUS) McLaren Sporting Director
26.07.2014- Qualifying, A message to Michael Schumacher

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.


richard

January 08, 2014 1:12 PM

laughing gas. why on earth is someones head going to roll? nobody was at fault. schumi was on the prepared piste where there are no rocks. run was a blue or red which means even a person with 2-3 years experience can ski on it safely. schumis helmet cam apparenty shows that he (for whatever reason) went outside the boundaries, into an area of deep snow with rocks in it. and he fell, hitting his head on one of the rocks. plain simple accident. I have fallen,even when not moving, and torn a ligament , and i have had over 50 years skiing experience. and only last year, did I purchase and use a helmet. accidents DO happen, and no-one is to blame

Taipan

January 08, 2014 3:44 PM
Last Edited 349 days ago

Laughing gas, Who's head's going to roll? Are you expecting prosecutors to have the rock in the dock? This report says Michael's speed is hard to evaluate from the video. The BBC says the video shows that he was travelling at a speed only an experienced skier would attempt and another F1 site claims the video shows that he was travelling slowly but they all agree that speed wasn't an issue. At least they agree on something. Does a simple skiing accident really require an investigation?



© 1999 - 2014 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.