Aprilia Monza appeal rejected, results finally confirmed

The provisional results from the second World Superbike race at Monza in May are officially confirmed with Tom Sykes retaining third position, ahead of Sylvain Guintoli.
The long-running dispute over the final classification for the second World Superbike race at Monza appears to have come to a definite conclusion with the ruling that Tom Sykes can retain his previously provisional third place over Sylvain Guintoli.

The original dispute occurred back in May when Sykes overtook Guintoli for third position on the final lap of the Italian race, only to cut across the Roggia chicane moments later.

Insisting he was well past Guintoli before he ran on at the chicane, Sykes defended himself by saying he was forced to shortcut the bend to avoid an early-braking Marco Melandri ahead before pointing out that he had also returned to the circuit in the proper manner.

With Sykes going on to retain the position ahead of Guintoli, Aprilia subsequently launched a protest, which they were initially successful with, before a counter-protest from Kawasaki would see Sykes reinstated to third place once again.

Another protest from Aprilia would duly follow, prompting the case to be referred to the FIM International Disciplinary Court. With representatives making their case in July, a formal decision has now been made with Sole Judge Jan Stovicek duly rejecting Aprilia's appeal.

A statement from the FIM CDI reads as follows:

“Following the decision taken by the FIM Stewards at Race 2 of the FIM Superbike round held on 12 May in Monza (ITA) and counting towards the 2013 FIM Superbike World Championship to cancel the drop of position sanction imposed by the Race Direction on rider Tom Sykes (Kawasaki Racing Team), the Aprilia Racing Team and rider Sylvain Guintoli lodged an appeal with the FIM CDI.

“The CDI held a hearing in the case at the FIM headquarters in Mies (Switzerland) on 16 July 2013. The parties and their representatives were duly heard.

“The CDI in the person of Sole Judge Mr Jan Stovicek (Czech Republic) rejected the Appeal lodged with the FIM International Disciplinary Court (CDI) by Mr Sylvain Jean-Baptiste Guintoli and Aprilia Racing Team against the decision of the FIM Stewards taken on 12 May 2013.

“The CDI noted that there was no infringement of the FIM Superbike Regulations by the Rider Tom Sykes when he left the track at the entry to the “La Roggia” chicane as he used the route indicated and returned to the track at the prescribed spot.”

The ruling means Sykes retains his third place, in doing so maintaining his slender lead over Guintoli in the overall standings with four rounds of the season to go. Had the decision gone in Aprilia's favour, the reversal of results would have seen Guintoli move back into the lead of the standings ahead of this weekend's races in Turkey.

Related Pictures

Click on relevant pic to enlarge
Eugene Laverty, Chaz Davies, Sykes, German WSBK Race 2 2013
Sykes, Race Start, German WSBK Race 2 2013
Melandri, Sykes, Chaz Davies, German WSBK Race 1 2013
Sykes, Kawasaki team, German WSBK Race 1 2013
Sykes, German WSBK Race 1 2013
Sykes, German WSBK Race 2 2013
Jonathan Rea, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea, Jerez WSBK 2016
Sykes, Jerez WSBK 2016
Sykes, Jerez WSBK 2016
Sykes, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea, Davies  and Sykes, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea, Davies  and Sykes, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016
Sykes, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea and Sykes, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016
Jonathan Rea and Sykes, WSBK Race2, Jerez WSBK 2016

Join the conversation - Add your comment

Please login or register before adding your comments.

Although the administrators and moderators of this website will attempt to keep all objectionable comments off these pages, it is impossible for us to review all messages. All messages express the views of the poster, and neither Crash Media Group nor Crash.Net will be held responsible for the content of any message. We do not vouch for or warrant the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any message, and are not responsible for the contents of any message. If you find a message objectionable, please contact us and inform us of the problem or use the [report] function next to the offending post. Any message that does not conform with the policy of this service can be edited or removed with immediate effect.


September 13, 2013 5:01 PM

This is just ridiculous that they announced this statement after almost five months! In my opinion stewarts should make the decision as soon as posible, before next round, because riders should know how much risk they could take in fight for the points in every single round. Also they should make rules much more simple.

© 1999 - 2016 Crash Media Group

The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.